Populated Towns Cost Four Times More to Build Than Dungeons, Says Obsidian Design Director

image 3
🔊 Listen to the summary

Building a believable, populated town in a role-playing game typically costs four times as much to develop as a dungeon of comparable map size, according to Obsidian Entertainment studio design director Josh Sawyer.

Speaking in a Q&A vlog on his YouTube channel about why contemporary urban settings remain rare in role-playing titles, Sawyer explained that settlements require far more production resources to feel authentic. Populated hubs demand dense clusters of non-player characters, expansive dialogue scripting, and a significant volume of custom art and setup work that standard combat areas do not require.

Sawyer noted that this cost disparity frequently manifested across his work at both Obsidian and Black Isle Studios, often catching developers off guard toward the end of a project. He cited the city of Twin Elms from Pillars of Eternity as a prime example, acknowledging that the location proved to be both a major pacing issue for players and an exceptionally expensive undertaking that consumed massive amounts of development time.

While acknowledging the difficulty, Sawyer pointed out that certain games have successfully pulled off dense cities. He highlighted Athkatla from Baldur’s Gate 2 alongside narrative-focused titles like Disco Elysium and Zero Parades, though he noted the latter two projects gained an advantage by avoiding the need to balance believable combat encounters throughout their streets.

Source: PC Gamer