Polygon Reflects on Seven Live-Service Games Shut Down Before Reaching Their Potential

image 586
🔊 Listen to the summary

Live-service titles continue to struggle with long-term survival in an increasingly crowded market, with Polygon highlighting seven notable games that were shuttered prematurely despite distinct concepts and dedicated player bases.

Among the highlighted titles was Epic Games’ third-person MOBA Paragon, which launched in 2016 featuring vertical terrain and action-oriented combat. Epic ultimately shifted its development resources away from the project to support the rapidly surging success of Fortnite, leading to Paragon‘s closure in April 2018. Similarly, Turtle Rock Studios and 2K Games’ asymmetrical shooter Evolve debuted with strong unit shipments, but heavy launch monetization that surpassed $130 on top of the $60 retail price alienated audiences. A 2016 free-to-play reboot delayed the inevitable before official servers were pulled in September 2018.

Major franchise adaptations also struggled to maintain momentum. Square Enix saw major financial setbacks with Marvel’s Avengers, developed by Crystal Dynamics and Eidos. While the single-player campaign earned praise, the live-service multiplayer mode suffered from repetitive loops, cosmetic microtransactions, and bugs during the COVID-19 pandemic, prompting Square Enix to shut it down in September 2023 and sell its North American studios. Square Enix also sunset the mobile and PC title Mobius Final Fantasy in mid-2020 after monetization controversies regarding specific character classes dampened enthusiasm, despite narrative leadership from franchise veterans Yoshinori Kitase and Kazushige Nojima.

Other games fell victim to technical or engagement roadblocks. Monolith Productions’ shooter Gotham City Impostors folded in 2014 when the GameSpy server infrastructure shut down, though dedicated fans still organize matches through Discord. Sony’s vehicular arena combat game Destruction AllStars lost traction due to microtransactions and repetitive gameplay, resulting in its delisting ahead of a planned server shutdown. Meanwhile, Wildlight Entertainment’s Unreal Engine 5 shooter Highguard, which combined fantasy combat with base destruction, rapidly lost users after launch, resulting in withdrawn funding from backer Tencent and abrupt studio layoffs.

Source: polygon.com