Garmin and Qalo have both released screenless fitness trackers priced around $200 that do not require mandatory subscription memberships, challenging the business model popularized by rivals like Whoop. Garmin launched its $199.99 Cirqa in July, while Qalo introduced the $199.95 SL-1 roughly ten weeks later in late September.
While sharing a nearly identical entry price and lack of required ongoing fees, the two wearables diverge significantly in their physical capabilities. Garmin rates the Cirqa for 5 ATM water resistance, allowing use in depths up to 50 meters, alongside an operating temperature range running from minus 4 to 140 degrees Fahrenheit. The tracker features over 80 activity modes, vibration alerts, a multicolor LED indicator, and the ability to pull location data from a paired smartphone’s GPS. In contrast, Qalo’s SL-1 carries an IP68 rating certified for depths up to 10 meters, works across an operating range of 14 to 113 degrees Fahrenheit, and lacks connected GPS or vibration feedback.
Qalo focuses its hardware advantage on battery endurance, advertising 12 or more days of life per charge using a magnetic USB-C charging cradle. Garmin claims up to 10 days of runtime for the Cirqa, which relies on a proprietary cable that charges the band in roughly 90 minutes.
Both devices are eligible for FSA and HSA funds and share core biometric tracking, including optical heart rate monitoring, skin temperature, blood oxygen levels, heart rate variability, sleep stages, and stress. Software ecosystems mark another divide between the two. While Qalo packages all app metrics into its free software, Garmin includes an optional Connect+ membership tier at $6.99 per month or $69.99 annually to unlock advanced features like AI-driven insights, performance dashboards, and guided workouts.
Source: engadget.com



