A federal appeals court is considering whether law enforcement agencies violate the U.S. Constitution by querying automated license plate reader databases without first obtaining a warrant. The legal battle before the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals stems from a Texas armed robbery conviction that resulted in a 60-year prison sentence.
The case involves Charles Brownlee, who was convicted of carrying out five armed robberies across the Dallas-Fort Worth area in 2024. Investigators identified the vehicle associated with the crimes by utilizing Flock’s searchable database, filtering for an SUV matching witness descriptions near several crime scenes and subsequently tracking its location. Brownlee’s defense counsel, Matthew Wright, argues that piecing together an individual’s travel patterns through this surveillance network constitutes a search under the Fourth Amendment.
During proceedings, Justice Department attorney Michael Weisbuch defended the warrantless search, stating that Flock cameras merely capture sporadic, intermittent sightings rather than unbroken surveillance. However, Chief Judge Jennifer Walker Elrod questioned how that logic will hold up as surveillance camera networks grow more prevalent. Prosecutors further argue that Brownlee lacks legal standing to contest the vehicle records because he was riding as a passenger in his sister’s car, while also noting other evidence contributed to his arrest.
The Fifth Circuit previously upheld warrantless automated plate reader usage in March 2026 in United States v. Porter, reasoning that camera captures lacked the continuous monitoring capabilities of cellular location records while acknowledging the technology still allows authorities to retrace past trips. Earlier this month, a separate U.S. District Court judge reached a different conclusion, determining that an officer’s warrantless query of historical plate-reader logs violated Fourth Amendment rights.
Source: carscoops.com



