Polygon Ranks Fantasy Literature’s Greatest Battles, Crowning Tolkien’s Pelennor Fields

image 1128
🔊 Listen to the summary

J.R.R. Tolkien’s Battle of the Pelennor Fields has been highlighted as the pinnacle of fantasy warfare in a retrospective ranking published by Polygon, which evaluated the genre’s most memorable military clashes.

The climactic conflict from The Lord of the Rings earned the top spot for its dramatic culmination outside Minas Tirith. The sequence weaves together the desperate defense of Gondor against Sauron’s army, the massive charge of the Rohirrim cavalry, King Théoden’s final stand, Éowyn’s confrontation with the Witch-king, and Aragorn’s decisive arrival on the field.

Robert Jordan’s The Wheel of Time earned two separate entries on the list. Polygon highlighted the sprawling conflict outside Cairhien, where Rand al’Thor led an allied coalition against tens of thousands of Shaido Aiel, as well as the rescue at Dumai’s Wells, which introduced the terrifying power of the Asha’man using channeling with the efficiency of modern artillery.

George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire was recognized for the Battle of the Blackwater, focusing on Tyrion Lannister’s tactical defense of King’s Landing against Stannis Baratheon’s fleet through the use of naval maneuvers and destructive wildfire.

Prolonged fortress defenses also earned high marks. David Gemmell’s Legend was featured for the siege of Dros Delnoch, in which an outnumbered garrison including the veteran warrior Druss defended six concentric fortress walls against the Nadir horde. Steven Erikson’s Malazan Book of the Fallen was cited for the siege of Capustan, where Mortal Sword Itkovian and the Grey Swords mounted a desperate defense against the Pannion Domin.

Source: polygon.com